TEXT_SIZE
Please update your Flash Player to view content.

Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decision

Dan McDonald
Staff Writer
5/30/2012

 

Plumas County’s Board of Supervisors said that big corporations in this country have way too much political clout.

And they unanimously passed a resolution to emphasize the point.

During their May 15 meeting the supervisors voted to adopt a resolution rejecting a 2010 United States Supreme Court decision. The resolution called for the state’s federal representative to push for a constitutional amendment.

The landmark decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission held that the First Amendment prohibited the government from restricting independent political expenditures by corporations and unions.

Since that ruling, scores of citizen initiatives and municipal government resolutions have been adopted calling for a constitutional amendment.

The argument is that the Supreme Court’s decision states that corporations are people, and have the same constitutional rights as people. As a result, corporations can use their money to buy political influence that most citizens can’t afford.

“The effects of the Citizens United (ruling) are devastating to our democracy,” county resident Mark Mihevc said. “Corporations and the wealthy give millions and millions and millions of dollars to buy politicians who will do their bidding, and have nothing to do with the needs of our county and 310 million Americans.”

The board’s largely symbolic decision to adopt the resolution drew loud applause from resolution supporters in the audience.

“I think everybody in this nation is pretty fed up with federal (and) state representatives who get in office and start campaigning non-stop for their next election,” Supervisor Lori Simpson said. “They need to get down to business. And corporations need to take that money and create jobs in the USA.

“So I make a motion to approve (the) resolution,” she said.

As the crowd applauded, Supervisor Terry Swofford seconded the motion. All five supervisors voted approval in a roll-call vote.

“I absolutely, 100-percent support what you are trying to do with this,” Supervisor Sherrie Thrall said. “When I saw the Supreme Court’s decision I was astounded, knowing the impact it would have on elections.”

Before the vote, county residents Marsha Roby, Trish Taylor and Mihevc gave passionate arguments for amending the U.S. Constitution.

“People say an amendment to the Constitution is never going to happen. They say it’s a hard process and it’s just impossible,” Taylor said. “But there have been amendments to the Constitution that had to do with the right to vote and democracy at a really primary level. ... It took 150 years (before an amendment) for women to get the right to vote.”

Roby said 172 similar resolutions have been passed across the country since the 2010 ruling. She said the grassroots movement is necessary to show the federal government that changes have to be made soon.

“We are seeing the detrimental impacts of the Citizens United ruling every day,” Roby said. “With the emergence of Super PACs (wealthy political action committees), corporations and wealthy individuals are buying the allegiance of legislators and presidential candidates, influencing elections and drowning out the voices of ordinary citizens like you and me.

“They have been using their new buying power to crush the union movements, eliminate wage protections, privatize everything from schools to Social Security, etc.

“They are dynamiting the underpinnings of the middle class,” Roby said. “And taking away the public tools that ordinary people must have to do the extraordinary things that truly make America great.”

 

Comments  

 
-1#1ResidentBill Powers2012-05-30 05:33
My only dismay is that only 172 local governments have passed similar resolutions. Like Congress, the Supreme Court is polarized, and this is an example of that result. Government shouldn't be something that is bought and sold!
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
+3#2RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionWhat will you do2012-05-30 06:27
Twenty nine of the top thirty corporation pay no income taxes. They pay more to employ lobbyists to tell our elected what the rates should be. Corporations that employ workers outside U.S. receive tax credits that differ not from a U.S. worker. Think about it on your next Walmart trip.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
+1#3RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionIn the news today2012-05-30 07:57Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
0#4RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionA Realist2012-05-30 10:44
I have known Bill Powers and Terry Swafford for many years. I respect them both deeply.
I will however have to emphatically disagree with them in this case. The problem is with the LEGAL definition of a corporation. It is that which they should protest, NOT A US SUPREME COURT DECISION!
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-3#5RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionMark Mihevc2012-05-30 14:13
A Realist, that's the problem. There is no legal definition that states 'corporations are people'. Only conservative corporatist Supreme Courts state 'corporations are people'. This defies the Constitution and common sense.

And, it only serves to end our democracy.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-1#6RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionBill Powers2012-05-30 22:54
This is the piece to which I refer:
cbsnews.com/.../...
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
0#7RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionMark Mihevc2012-05-31 06:12
A Realist, I know the Constitution does not even mention corporations or business. Article 1 - 8 states Congress regulates Commerce.

So, show me in 'corporate law' where it states corporations are people...

Obviously you have something to support your assertions...
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-1#8RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionA Realist2012-05-31 09:29
Mark Mihevc, What in the world are you talking about? Are you off your meds? Are you aware that corporations are legal entities unto themselves? Indeed, that is the definition of a corporation - a wholly seperate legal entity akin to an individual. Hence the proper ruling by the USSC.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-1#9Missing the Big Picture3Stooges2012-05-31 09:50
It is unfortunate the BOS got sucked into what is a national campaign with a parade of left-wing interests to gain political advantage by restricting the associational freedom and activism of the people (employees, shareholders, and customers) who constitute the evil "corporations."
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
0#10RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionKurt Montandon2012-05-31 12:53
restricting the associational freedom and activism of the people (employees, shareholders, and customers) who constitute the evil "corporations."

If the employees, shareholders, and customers had any say in corporate political spending, that might be true. In reality, not so much.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-2#11Kenny Knew Better3Stooges2012-05-31 14:47
If the employees, shareholders, and customers had any say in corporate political spending, that might be true. In reality, not so much

Sorry, for a moment I forgot the "Occupy" understanding of business comes from the Walmart episode of South Park.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
+3#12RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionA Realist2012-05-31 15:08
I have been pretty hard on Mark. Actually it is the board of Supervisors who need to focus on our local problems and not make symbolic gestures to the USSC. Get out your coins ladies and gentlemen, there are important decisions to be made.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
+2#13RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionMark Mihevc2012-05-31 18:02
It is sad that people here are defending the absurdity that corporations are people. Corporations and the rich are buying our democracy and their only goal is for themselves. And it has nothing to do with our livelihoods.

They could care less what happens to the 300 million of us.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
+1#14RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionMark Mihevc2012-05-31 18:12
Unfortunately,far too many people have lost the ability to think and reason. Arguing for the ludicrous notion that 'corporations are people, money is speech' proves my point. This stupidity,ignorance, and lack of common human decency is killing our democracy, our country and Earth.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-3#15RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionKurt Montandon2012-05-31 20:27
Quoting 3Stooges:
Sorry, for a moment I forgot the "Occupy" understanding of business comes from the Walmart episode of South Park.


That utterly fails to address my reality-based point.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-1#16Focus on the Union CorruptionGenevieve Dumonte2012-05-31 20:28
The BOS should examine the political clout of the Unions.The unions buy politicians, and have caused over bureaucratized county governments and over-pensioned county retirees. Plumas County is no different.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-4#17RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionMark Mihevc2012-06-01 12:47
Please note that Unions are *Workers* - you, me, our neighbors - that unite together so that workers get fair pay, benefits, pensions, and safe working conditions.

People should be demanding what workers once had - safe & reliable pensions. It is a race to the top - not the bottom.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-4#18RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionMark Mihevc2012-06-01 12:52
Also, unions must follow the same rules as corporations. The legal entity called Unions are not 'people'.

Only real people can donate and vote for candidates...who best represents what they believe in and desire.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
0#19RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decision3Stooges2012-06-01 13:39
Actually, there is substance there for anyone who understands the South Park reference.

If you want to police the comments, maybe pick on the made-up quote that "corporations are people." The only place in Citizens United where people/corps are discussed says exactly the opposite.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
0#20RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionA Realist2012-06-01 15:21
Mark, unions and their undue and likely illegal political influence are the main thing ruining this once great country. All unions should be immediately disbanded. The corporate influence is the only minor counterbalance to these miscreants.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
+1#21Unions aren't peopleGerald Scully2012-06-01 15:25
[quote name="Mark Mihevc"]Please note that Unions are *Workers* - you, me, our neighbors - that unite together so that workers get fair pay, benefits, pensions, and safe working conditions.


Unions are political machines. Ask Jerry Brown, Gov. MoonBeam is a puppet for the unions.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
+5#22Unions are breaking this Country and CountyBernie Williams2012-06-01 15:41
Union corruption is apparent. The California Courthouse construction boondoggle is Jerry Brown creating union jobs.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
+3#23Unions aren't PeopleGenevieve Dumonte2012-06-01 15:55
[quote name="Mark Mihevc"]Please note that Unions are *Workers* - ...that unite together so that workers get fair pay, benefits, pensions...

You live in a fantasy world. Unions haven't been this in a long time. Jerry Brown & his train to Victorville at $69 mil, union pacification.
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
0#24Read "Remember When" for this week, 25 years agoGenevieve Dumonte2012-06-01 16:04
25 YEARS AGO.............1987
Plumas County Board of Supervisors members Don Woodhall, Bill Coates, John Schramel, Jim Gossett and Leonard Ross locked up the front entrance door of the Plumas County courthouse with chains as a symbolic action to protest unfunded programs mandated by the State
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-1#25RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionMark Mihevc2012-06-01 16:44
What do you all have against unions anyway? This is where American workers unite for better pay, benefits, and conditions.

How can union workers who make what 50-150k compete with say the multi-billionaire Koch brothers or the oil cos?
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
0#26RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionMark Mihevc2012-06-01 16:47
And, who cares *if* Brown or anyone creates 'union' jobs. Isn't a job a job? Do you get mad if your sister, your best friend, your neighbor gets a union job? Are you not happy for them? Or do you prefer them not to work and suffer? Do you turn down a union job and stay in unemployment?
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-1#27RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionMark Mihevc2012-06-01 16:49
And really, please tell me why you all are so against unions. What did they do to you? How have workers in a union or the union itself harm America?

Or is it that you just are following orders from fox news and limpbaugh...and have no clue why you 'hate' unions...
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
+4#28RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionoracle2012-06-01 17:12
Why hate unions?

I don't like certain unions that are running our state and local gov's into bankruptcy.

reason.com/.../...
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
-3#29RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionMark Mihevc2012-06-01 17:28
Oracle, imagine you are a worker who negotiated pay and benefits. Then imagine they want to take it all away from you because they prefer to give more money to the wealthy than you...

How would you like them taking away your livelihood? Don't *you* want want a decent wage and retirement?
Quote| Report to administrator
 
 
+1#30RE: Supervisors pass resolution to reject Supreme Court decisionA Realist2012-06-01 21:09
Mark, You aren't even making sense. You are simply a union apologist. Unions exist only to enrich union bosses and politicians.
Quote| Report to administrator
 

Add comment

Feather Publishing encourages civil discussion on news stories that are important to our community. We do ask that commenters follow certain rules of conduct. Keep your comments on the topic at hand. Threats, insults, lies, and inappropriate language are prohibited. Just as with our letters to the editor we want you to be accountable for your comments so we ask that you use your full real name. We reserve the right to delete any comments that do not comply with these rules of conduct. Commenters who repeatedly do not comply will be prohibited from posting further comments.
Comments are limited to 300 characters. If you would like to post a longer message, please submit a letter to the editor. Submit a letter to the editor. Letters to the editor are limited to a maximum of 300 words. Deadline for submittal is noon on Thursdays.


Move
-

Sports Headlines

Top Headline

Greenville loses to American Christian

Greenville loses to American Christian

Greenville’s James Martinez rounds third and gives his coach Mike Chelotti a high five after hitting a homer during the Indians’ game against American Christian...

Read More...

175 mile Sierra Nevada Relay to run through Plumas County

175 mile Sierra Nevada Relay to run through Plumas County

This gorgeous view of mountains towering over a valley is one of many that runners in the upcoming Sierra Nevada Relay will encounter. The relay starts at Donner...

Read More...

Fishing Report for the week of 5/16/2013

Fishing Report for the week of 5/16/2013

Unsettled weather has ended; time to hit the water Ben Williams, a Lake Almanor Fly Fishing Company Guide landed this monster rainbow from Goodrich Creek near...

Read More...
Facebook Image
Local Events

Contact Us

up_contact

Visitors Guide
Yellow Page Directory
Yellow Pages

National Headlines

Dining Guide
 
Plumas County
Restaurant

 

Moving and Storage
Forest Stweardship
 
ForestStwd.gif
Help Wanted
Help Wanted

Help WantedClick to see current job opportunities

Advertise with us

LassenNews.com
"); pageTracker._trackPageview(); } catch(err) {}