NewLogo
  • image
  • Linda Gillam
  • almanor energy
  • coldwellbanker

State accuses auto repair shop owner of violations

Dan McDonald
Staff Writer
12/14/2011

The owner of a Quincy auto repair shop is facing possible discipline from the state’s Department of Consumer Affairs.

The Bureau of Automotive Repair has accused Corey’s Automotive & Smog owner Jim Corey of 25 violations stemming from four customer complaints dating back to September 2009.

Many of the violations reportedly occurred during an undercover operation by the bureau.

Corey is scheduled to have a hearing before an administrative law judge May 23 – 24, 2012, in Sacramento.

According to a 23-page document by the Bureau of Automotive Repair (BAR), dated Aug. 31, Corey is accused of “dishonesty, fraud or deceit” and other violations associated with repair work performed at his East Quincy shop.

During a Wednesday, Dec. 7, interview at his business, Corey insisted he is innocent of the accusations. But he said the charges alone would put him out of business.

“Even though I haven’t committed a crime, it’s the seriousness of the charges that people will pay attention to,” Corey said. “And people are going to say to me, ‘Well, if you didn’t do it, why are they going after you? You must have done something or they wouldn’t be going after you.’

“But it’s all hearsay,” he said. “The people that made the complaints won’t even come to court.”

Consumer Affairs spokesman Glenn Mason said his office conducted an undercover operation at Corey’s business in response to the consumer complaints.

“Every complaint we get is investigated,” Mason said. “If we get a number of complaints, we send in an undercover unit.”

According to the report, BAR sent an undercover 1994 Ford Explorer to Corey’s shop Sept. 29, 2010. The report stated the violations identified during that operation accounted for 13 of the 25 “causes for discipline” identified in the state’s accusations.

“The reason we (go undercover) is that anybody can complain about a repairman if they feel they aren’t treated well. We know that,” Mason said. “That’s why we investigated this ourselves.”

Mason said the undercover operations are “very thorough.” He said vehicles used are thoroughly checked out at the BAR lab and documented. Photos are taken of all the parts that might be examined by a mechanic.

“We know exactly what is wrong with a car when we take it in,” Mason said.

 

The sting

According to the Bureau of Auto Repair report, the work that needed to be done on the undercover Ford Explorer was replacement of the following components: the left front brake rotor, the right rear brake drum, one marker lamp bulb and the high-beam indicator bulb.

On Sept. 29, 2010, a bureau employee took the Explorer to Corey’s and requested a brake, lamp and smog inspection.

A verbal estimate from Corey of $260 was agreed upon for the inspection.

The agent later was told the Explorer didn’t pass the inspection because both front rotors and brake pads needed to be replaced and the anti-lock brake system (ABS) had a problem that required further diagnosis.

The report also stated the vehicle failed the lamp inspection because the high-beam indicator and right front marker lamp were not working. The vehicle passed the smog inspection.

On Oct. 11, the undercover agent reportedly contacted Corey’s and requested an estimate to repair the Explorer.

Corey’s repair estimate was reportedly $869.90, which would cover replacement of the front brake pads and two rotors, and supply two bottles of brake fluid and three cans of brake cleaner.

The report states Corey also told the agent that the vehicle needed a further diagnostic check for an additional $80, and that the cost to repair the lights would be $40 plus parts.

When the agent retrieved the Explorer, the total cost of the repairs was $1,109.91. The agent also received the brake and lamp certificates and a copy of the invoice.

According to the report, a bureau representative inspected the Explorer and found the following:

—The high-beam indicator lamp had not been replaced, rendering the vehicle unable to pass the lamp inspection.

—Corey failed to replace the oversized right rear brake drum, rendering the vehicle unable to pass the brake inspection.

—Corey unnecessarily replaced both front brake calipers and brake pads, the right front rotor and both front wheel seals, and unnecessarily inspected the ABS system.

—Corey failed to pressure bleed the braking system as invoiced. In addition, the repair was not necessary, according to the report.

 

The fallout

According to the Department of Consumer Affairs spokesman Russ Heimerich, Corey could have his automotive repair license suspended or revoked if he is found to be guilty.

The judge’s decision can be accepted, modified or rejected by the director of Consumer Affairs, according to Heimerich.

Mason said in some cases a settlement hearing could take place before the scheduled hearing with the judge.

“There could be a settlement,” Mason said. “There could be a number of things that could happen. He could be fined or suspended for a day or two.”

He could also have his repair license placed on probation and be ordered to pay for the cost of the undercover operation.

Corey said he feels like he has already lost the case, even though he said he could produce evidence to prove he did nothing wrong.

“You expect that if you are going to go to a trial, that you will have 12 jurors that you are going to submit your information to and you have a chance,” Corey said. “But I’m going in front of hanging judge Roy Bean. That’s what I’m up against. I will never win.”

Corey said he considered hiring an attorney, but he said a lawyer he contacted wanted $2,500 just to take the case.

“Do you know what I made last year, gross, out of this place? … $11,750,” Corey said. “So you think I can afford to hire an attorney?

“I have so many tax liens … liens everywhere. I have a lien from (Feather Publishing). I just don’t make any money anymore. Everything I own, I’ve sold, just to be able to keep my ‘open’ sign on. … If you print (this story), you are going to kill me. I will be out of business.”

 

avatar
Fire was girlfriends house before he knew her. His house still standing. <br />Shop burned - possibly by same person who burnt girlfriends house. <br />Get your facts. He is arrogant but he is a good honest mechanic.
VOTES:-1
avatar
I was warned not to go to Coreys Auto.I did thinking I would give him a chance to prove himself..boy did he!Just don't ever have him do a 're-do'..whether it was poor workmanship or bad parts he will charge more per hour on the 're-do' and you pay all the labor.
VOTES:1
avatar
Dude got busted in a sting! What more do you need? He is a crook. He has been pulling his **** for years and of course he dont rip off everyone who comes in but he is rippin people off. And do you really believe he only made 11,000 dollars what a lie! Its obvious he is into tax fraud to.
VOTES:2
avatar
I stand corrected,mr.corey sold me 2 snow mobiles,$2000 each 1 wrecked the other dont run,Promised me 2 year guarentee!now he has no time to fix broke one very bad bussiness man.
VOTES:2
avatar
I know for a fact that this guy is a ripoff. He not only scams people and destroys their vehicles but he lies on court documents and tries to pay off any county employee that goes into his shop. I am thankful that the State is finally opening their eyes to this crook. He deserves to be in jail.
VOTES:9
avatar
Lol, a friend just sent me this. I read it in complete laughter. I know Jim of Corey's Auto and I'm just laughing knowing what scum our news 'reporters' are now. Guess there is no more need for truth in the news. Sorry about this dig on you Jim. Glad your above all this and for good reason.
VOTES:-17
avatar
Im writing in concerns with such a publishing company. Sad today to know that 'anyone' can publish 'anything' about a man all based upon hearsay. I've known Mr. Corey for nearly 10 years. One of the last few 'good guys' left in this world. Sad that a publishing company woul print garbage on purpose.
VOTES:-13
avatar
Yes, I know for a fact he is a ripoff.
VOTES:9
avatar
Wow looks like we got an old-fashioned linch bob now!
<br />It's spelled "lynch mob", and it looks like a lot of people don't like to be cheated out of their hard-earned cash. No one should have to shell out cash for unnecessary repairs on their car, it isn't right.
VOTES:11
avatar
Wow looks like we got an old-fashioned linch bob now!
VOTES:-10
avatar
a couple years back I was with a friend in court here in Quincy and Corey was in there for a case that was brought against him for ripping someone off, I don't know him personally but I was shocked at what a smart ass he was in the court room. He made smart ass remarks and laughed. Not impressive
VOTES:12
avatar
I use to work for a different repair shop and we helped lots of people that corey screwed over. My husband went there once for a smog and it failed i told him to go somewhere else which he did and passed. All this was in quincy......hmmm weird right?
VOTES:9
avatar
The hole problem here is not that coreys auto hasent ripped any one off,just charged jobs what they were wourth.Nobody likes to pay big bills.
VOTES:-15
avatar
Sorry for those who have had problems but my experience has been different. Once he spent a few hours working on my boat. He fixed it and then showed me how to do it in the future in case it happened again. The charge: zero. And he doesn't know me from Adam. His work for me has always been good.
VOTES:-7
avatar
It's a good think you did take it to a different shop. It looks like you saved some money there.
VOTES:9
avatar
I am pretty sure that CO emission standards are less stringent than CA so it is entirely possible to pass there and not here.
VOTES:-11
avatar
When moving from out of state a few years ago I went to Cory's for a smog check. I was told that I needed a new catalytic converter, and some work to my gas tank to pass. In CO I did not have any problems with my annual smog. I then took it to a different shop and it passed with flying colors..hmmm
VOTES:11
avatar
M.Vickers girl friends house was his house,was arson by her ex-husband.shop was an electrical fire,old building!
VOTES:-16
avatar
Would somebody please step up to the plate;HAS anybody actually been ripped off by mr.corey or is it all just what you heard.In my 15 years of bussiness with mr.corey i have not been ripped off.GOD BLESS YOU JIM.
VOTES:-14
avatar
I am amazed he lasted this long. His house burnt and then his shop burnt, very suspicious! You screw enough people in a small town, your bound to fail.
<br /><br />Girlfriends house burnt too. That makes three.
VOTES:16

Camp-Layman-Web-Button

Slusher-Web-Button

HighTechBtn

PlumasDiningCoverWeb
Setting
  • Search area
    • Site
    • Web
  • Search type
    • Web
    • Image
    • News
    • Video
  • Power by JLex
RobinBtn
Yellow Pages
VGCover