Please update your Flash Player to view content.
   These are the stories we are working on for this week's newspaper:
  • Deputy shooting fallout: The children of a Portola man who was shot and killed at Eastern Plumas Health Care last year are seeking millions of dollars in damages.
  • The trout must go: The state is planning to pull all of the brook trout out of a Plumas County lake in order to protect the yellow-legged frog.
  • Inspections delayed: Cal Fire was scheduled to begin property inspections this week, but decided to wait until the public could better understand what the inspectors are doing.

State attorney general, environmental group appeal Framework decision

Delaine Fragnoli
Managing Editor

    Both the state attorney general’s office and Sierra Forest Legacy have filed notices with the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals of their intent to appeal a November ruling that determined what management rules should be in play on national forests in the Sierra Nevada.
    The two entities are appealing District Court Judge Morrison England’s decision in the so-called Framework case. England ruled Nov. 4 that although there were some procedural deficiencies, which he called “relatively minor,” in the Bush-era 2004 Sierra Nevada Framework, they did not mean the Forest Service should revert to the Clinton-era 2001 rules.
    In general, the 2004 plan contains more permissive standards for logging and would allow for full implementation of the Quincy Library Group program of fuel reduction.    
    The appeals are the latest in a long line of back-and-forth litigation between timber proponents and environmental opponents. England has typically favored the Forest Service in his rulings, while the appeals courts has generally been a more favorable venue for environmental plaintiffs.
    The appeals court has a mediation program to provide an opportunity for the litigants to discuss settlement before moving to briefing. According to one attorney involved in the case, the attorney general’s office has indicated it thinks there is a possibility of settlement. The attorney general is not asking for a stay.
    Sierra Forest Legacy, on the other hand, did not indicate any impulse to settle. The group did say it would seek a stay pending the appeal, probably to pre-empt timber harvest operations set to begin this spring, said the attorney.
    Settlement assessment conferences, the first step in the appeals court process, are scheduled for next month. Briefing dates have been calendared for March 22 for SFL and April 21 for the attorney general.
    The attorney said the notices of appeal “make it a higher likelihood that both the Sierra Forest Legacy and California attorney general will seek to have the 9th Circuit impose a broader injunction (e.g., set aside the 2004 Framework and only allow projects consistent with the 2001 Framework) than the limited relief granted by District Judge England, and will seek to have the 9th Circuit find more serious errors in the 2004 Framework and NEPA (National Environmental Policy Act) documents."
    John Sheehan of the Quincy Library Group said that while he expected SFL’s appeal, he was surprised by the attorney general’s action. Although settlement with SFL is unlikely, he held out hope something could be agreed upon with the attorney general.
    Under England’s decision, the Forest Service has until May 2010 to complete a supplemental environmental impact statement to address the procedural deficiencies he found in the 2001 Framework.

Sports Headlines

Top Headline

FRC rodeo to open arena for anyone brave enough

FRC rodeo to open arena for anyone brave enough

This cowboy holds on for dear life during last year’s saddle bronc riding portion of the rodeo clinic at Feather River College. For the third year, FRC’s rodeo...


As weather warms up, golf courses open for season

James Wilson Sports Editor 4/11/2014
  Fore! That word is once again heard in the distance in Plumas County. As springtime springs into action, golf courses across...


California Outdoors for the week of 4/11/2014

Carrie Wilson California Department of Fish and Wildlife   Fish and wildlife regulations don’t always keep up with latest technology Hunting with pellet rifles Question:...

Contact Us


Facebook Image
Local Events
Yellow Page Directory
Yellow Pages
Visitors Guide

National Headlines

"); pageTracker._trackPageview(); } catch(err) {}